Discovering the Charm of Fish Creek, Wisconsin: Your Ultimate Itinerary Including Fish Creek Hotels

The Ultimate Door County Getaway

Nestled in the picturesque Door County, Wisconsin, Fish Creek is a gem waiting to be explored. With its quaint charm, scenic landscapes, and a plethora of activities, it’s the perfect destination for a memorable getaway. Whether you’re a nature enthusiast, a foodie, or a history buff, Fish Creek has something for everyone. In this guide, we’ll take you through the ideal itinerary for your trip to Fish Creek, including where to stay like the best Fish Creek Hotels, what to do, and where to dine.

Where to Stay: Fresh Coast Motel – The Best of the Fish Creek Hotels

Your journey begins with finding the perfect place to stay, and in Fish Creek, you’re spoiled for choices. However, if you’re seeking comfort, convenience, and affordability, look no further than the Fresh Coast Motel. Located in the heart of downtown Fish Creek, just across from the public beach, this charming motel offers cozy coastal inspired rooms, modern amenities, and unparalleled hospitality. With its central location, you’ll have easy access to all the attractions Fish Creek has to offer. The Fresh Coast Motel also offers The Deckhouse, a five-bedroom luxury rental if you’re traveling with a group of up to 10.

Fresh Coast Motel
Discovering the Charm of Fish Creek, Wisconsin: Your Ultimate Itinerary Including Fish Creek Hotels 3

Fresh Coast Motel in Fish Creek, Wisconsin. Rendering of a double queen motel room, credit Fresh Coast Motel.

Day 1: Arrival and Exploration


Start your day with a hearty breakfast at one of Fish Creek’s charming cafes, like the Blue Horse Beach Cafe. From exquisite breakfast sandwiches to the ultimate breakfast burrito, you’ll find a variety of options to satisfy your cravings. After breakfast, take a leisurely stroll along Main Street, where you’ll discover quaint shops, art galleries, and boutiques selling everything from handmade crafts to locally sourced goods.


After exploring downtown Fish Creek, head to Peninsula State Park for an afternoon of outdoor adventure. Spanning over 3,700 acres, this scenic park offers hiking trails, bike paths, and breathtaking views of Lake Michigan. Don’t miss the opportunity to visit Eagle Tower for panoramic vistas of the surrounding landscape.


As the sun sets, unwind with a relaxing dinner at one of Fish Creek’s acclaimed restaurants. Whether you’re craving fresh seafood, farm-to-table cuisine, or classic comfort food, you’ll find plenty of options to tantalize your taste buds. After dinner, take a stroll along the waterfront and soak in the tranquil ambiance of Fish Creek at night. We highly recommend heading down the street from the Fresh Coast Motel to Barringer’s Restaurant or Hill Street, both have amazing food options of all kinds.

Hill Street Fish Creek
Discovering the Charm of Fish Creek, Wisconsin: Your Ultimate Itinerary Including Fish Creek Hotels 4

Hill Street Restaurant in Fish Creek | Photo Credit Destination Door County

Day 2: Nature and Culture


Rise and shine early to catch the rays of sunshine with the sunrise over Peninsula State Park and Fish Creek Harbor – a truly magical experience you won’t soon forget. After breakfast, embark on a scenic drive along the Door County Coastal Byway, where you’ll encounter breathtaking vistas, charming villages, and hidden gems waiting to be discovered.


Spend your afternoon exploring the rich cultural heritage of Fish Creek. Visit the Alexander Noble House Museum to learn about the area’s history and admire the beautifully preserved 19th-century architecture. If you’re a fan of the arts, don’t miss a visit to the Peninsula School of Art, where you can admire works by local and regional artists.


Wrap up your day with a leisurely dinner at a waterfront restaurant, where you can savor delicious cuisine while taking in stunning views of the sunset. After dinner, head back to the Fresh Coast Motel or The Deckhouse at the Fresh Coast and unwind with a glass of wine by the fire on the patio and watch the sun set over Fish Creek Harbor.

Day 3: Adventure and Relaxation


Kick off your final day in Fish Creek with an adrenaline-pumping adventure. Whether you’re into kayaking, paddleboarding, or zip-lining, you’ll find plenty of outdoor activities nearby to get your heart racing. For a more laid-back experience, opt for a scenic boat tour of the area’s pristine waters.


After an action-packed morning, treat yourself to a leisurely lunch at a cozy cafe or bistro. Take your time to savor the flavors of Door County’s culinary delights, from freshly caught fish to homemade pies.


As your trip comes to a close, take one last stroll along the beach and breathe in the fresh Lake Michigan air. Reflect on the memories you’ve made and the experiences you’ve shared during your time in Fish Creek. Before you bid farewell to this charming destination, be sure to pick up some souvenirs to remind you of your unforgettable adventure.

Conclusion: A Memorable Getaway Awaits in Fish Creek

From its scenic landscapes to its rich history and vibrant culture, Fish Creek, Wisconsin, offers a truly unforgettable experience for travelers of all ages. And with its central location and cozy accommodations, the Fresh Coast Motel is the perfect home base for your Door County adventure. So pack your bags, hit the road, and get ready to discover the charm of Fish Creek – you won’t be disappointed.

Fresh Coast Motel has been newly renovated in 2024 and is formerly known as By the Bay Motel.

Get on the list
Join our mailing list to stay in the know on all Fresh Coast happenings, updates, and exclusive offers!
All rights reserved
© 2024 Fresh Coast Motel
Expertly designed with love by
Addelise Design

Booking Inquiry Form