Door County, Wisconsin offers visitors a wide range of affordable and comfortable motel options that provide excellent value for your stay.
The best Door County motels combine convenient locations, essential amenities, and competitive pricing to create memorable experiences without breaking your budget. These accommodations range from waterfront properties to cozy inland spots near popular attractions.
You’ll find motels throughout Door County’s charming towns and scenic areas, each offering unique advantages depending on your travel needs.
Many feature amenities like indoor pools, complimentary breakfast, and proximity to state parks, beaches, and local attractions.
The variety ensures you can find the perfect base for exploring this popular Wisconsin destination.
Whether you’re planning a romantic getaway, family vacation, or solo adventure, Door County’s motels provide comfortable lodging that lets you focus on enjoying the area’s natural beauty and local culture.
Door County’s highest-rated motels combine excellent service with prime locations and competitive pricing.
These properties consistently earn praise from travelers for their cleanliness, staff, and amenities.
Spruce and Shore Motel, formerly known as Fish Creek Motel & Cottages, is a favorite among visitors for its clean rooms and friendly service.
Located near the shoreline, it offers easy access to both beaches and local attractions.
Fresh Coast Motel is another popular choice, known for its modern amenities and convenient location in Fish Creek.
Guests appreciate the comfortable beds and proximity to Door County’s scenic spots like Peninsula State Park.
Door County’s independent lodging scene shines—especially Fresh Coast Motel in Fish Creek and Spruce and Shore Motel in Sturgeon Bay. Both properties earn consistently high guest scores for spotless rooms, thoughtful touches, and genuinely friendly service. Fresh Coast carries 125+ five‑star Google reviews and recent features in Better Homes & Gardens and Midwest Living, while Spruce & Shore’s returning guests rave about its harbor-side convenience, easy parking, and locally savvy staff. With few big chains in the county, these two motels stand out by delivering personality, polish, and place-based experiences.
Traveling with a pup? Spruce and Shore Motel offers a limited number of pet-friendly accommodations (call ahead—these go fast in summer). Fresh Coast Motel can often accommodate pets in designated units as well;. Typical policies you’ll encounter across the county:
Some properties put together “pet packs” with local trail maps and treat bags—ask when booking.
While many Door County motels rely on the great outdoors for recreation, Spruce and Shore Motel keeps families happy with an outdoor pool Fresh Coast Motel leans into outdoor hangout spaces: fire
pit, public beach across the street and shaded seating make it easy to unwind after a day at Peninsula State Park.
Typical pool amenities elsewhere include heated indoor pools, whirlpools, and extended hours (6 AM–10 PM). Larger properties may add arcade rooms, picnic areas, or on-site walking paths.
Want waves outside your window? Spruce and Shore Motel puts you near
Fish Creek’s working waterfront—watch boats glide by and stroll to marina-side dining. Up in Fish Creek, Fresh Coast Motel is just steps from Green Bay shoreline sunsets and Peninsula State Park beaches.
If hiking and biking are your jam, Fresh Coast’s Fish Creek address can’t be beat—you’re within minutes of the park entrance, Nicolet Beach, and Eagle Bluff Lighthouse. Autumn color season and summer weekends fill fast, so book ahead.
Need year-round action? Spruce and Shore is your base for everything in walking distance including theaters, shopping, dining, and harbor walks are all within a few minutes on foot.
Fresh Coast Motel, renovated top-to-bottom in 2024 (formerly By the Bay Motel), provides a beach, nautical vibe and Door County nostalgia on the walls. Spruce and Shore brings in the nature vibes of Peninsula State Park and the surrounding beauty of our Door County outdoors.
Historic character you might notice:
Fresh Coast maximizes outdoor hangouts: Adirondack chairs, a communal fire pit and balcony areas to enjoy your morning coffee. Spruce and Shore’s upper-level rooms offer peeks of the harbor; waterfront benches nearby make sunrise viewing effortless.
Both motels cater to families: extra bedding options (sleeper sofas), and staff who’ll point you to the best ice cream stops and mini-golf deals. Spruce and Shore’s pool keeps kids busy; Fresh Coast’s proximity to Peninsula State Park and Fish Creek Public Beach deliver easy afternoon fun.
Book Fresh Coast and Spruce and Shore 3–6 months out for prime summer or fall weekends. Midweek stays (Sun–Thu) can save $20–$50/night.
Both motels offer their best rates and room choices when you book direct. Third-party OTAs trim inventory and tack on commission. Calling or booking on each motel’s site also makes it easier to request specific room types, pet rooms, or packages (park passes, dining credits, etc.).
Expect 24–48 hour cancellation windows off-season, and 7–14 days during summer/fall peaks. Late cancellations often forfeit one night’s rate. Always read the fine print and consider travel insurance for high-season trips.
You’ll want a car—Door County lacks public transit. Parking is generally free at motels and in most town centers. State parks charge $11/day or $39/year (WI resident rate). Summer traffic slows through Fish Creek and Ephraim mid-day; pad your schedule 10–15 minutes.
Door County’s best motel stays are independent, story-rich, and close to the action. Fresh Coast Motel (Fish Creek) and Spruce and Shore Motel (Fish Creek) deliver the comfort, character, and local know-how you need—without resorting to cookie-cutter chain vibes.
When choosing your stay, consider:
Book early for summer and fall, aim midweek for deals, and get ready to explore—your perfect Door County home base awaits at Fresh Coast or Spruce and Shore.
